| Name | Size | Tier | Heroes | Tags |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Piano | Medium | Gold | Vanessa | |
| Pickled Peppers | Medium | Silver | Jules | Food |
| Pierre Conditioner | Medium | Gold | Dooley | Friend |
| Piggles | Small | Bronze | Pygmalien | Toy |
| Piggles Board | Medium | Gold | Pygmalien | Toy |
| Piggles Launcher | Medium | Bronze | Pygmalien | ApparelToyWeapon |
| Piggles Protectors | Small | Bronze | Pygmalien | Toy |
| PiggleStorm Gaming House | Large | Gold | Pygmalien | Property |
| Piggy Bank | Small | Bronze | Pygmalien | Toy |
| Pillbuggy | Medium | Silver | Stelle | VehicleWeapon |
| Pilot's Wings | Small | Silver | Stelle | Apparel |
| Pinata | Medium | Bronze | Pygmalien | Toy |
| Pinwheel | Small | Bronze | Stelle | Toy |
| Piranha | Small | Bronze | Vanessa | AquaticFriendWeapon |
| Pistol Sword | Medium | Gold | Vanessa | Weapon |
| Pitchfork | Medium | Bronze | Pygmalien | ToolWeapon |
| Pizza | Medium | Silver | Jules | Food |
| Pizza Cutter | Small | Silver | Jules | ToolWeapon |
| Plague Glaive | Large | Gold | Mak | RelicWeapon |
| Plasma Grenade | Small | Bronze | Dooley | |
| Plasma Rifle | Medium | Gold | Dooley | TechWeapon |
| Pocket Knife | Small | Bronze | Karnok | ToolWeapon |
| Pogo Stick | Medium | Silver | Stelle | ToyVehicle |
| Poke | Small | Silver | Jules | Food |
| Pontoon Skimmer | Large | Silver | Pygmalien | AquaticVehicle |
| Poppy Field | Large | Gold | Mak | Property |
| Pop Snappers | Small | Bronze | Vanessa | Toy |
| Port | Large | Silver | Vanessa | AquaticProperty |
| Portable Shield Generator | Medium | Silver | Stelle | Vehicle |
| Portable Stove | Small | Bronze | Common | Tool |
| Potion Distillery | Large | Silver | Mak | PropertyTool |
| Potion Potion | Medium | Bronze | Mak | Potion |
| Powder Horn | Small | Bronze | Vanessa | Tool |
| Powder Keg | Medium | Gold | Vanessa | Weapon |
| Power Drill | Medium | Bronze | Dooley | ToolWeapon |
| Power Sander | Small | Bronze | Dooley | Tool |
| Precision Calipers | Small | Bronze | Stelle | Tool |
| Premium Green Piggles | Small | Bronze | Pygmalien | Toy |
| Premium Orange Piggles | Small | Bronze | Pygmalien | Toy |
| Premium Piggles | Small | Bronze | Pygmalien | Toy |
| Premium Red Piggles | Small | Bronze | Pygmalien | ToyWeapon |
| Premium Yellow Piggles | Small | Bronze | Pygmalien | Toy |
| Prep Station | Medium | Bronze | Jules | Tool |
| Pressure Heater | Medium | Silver | Stelle | Tool |
| Primal Core | Medium | Silver | Dooley | CoreDinosaurRelicWeapon |
| Private Hot Springs | Large | Silver | Pygmalien | Property |
| Private Jet | Large | Silver | Pygmalien | Vehicle |
| Private Runabout | Large | Silver | Stelle | VehicleWeapon |
| Proboscis | Small | Silver | Common | Weapon |
| Propeller | Medium | Silver | Stelle | Tool |